The Vendor Selection Process That Skips the Demo Bake-Off

Published: • Updated: • 6 min read

Two people work late at a desk testing software on a laptop and spreadsheet, while an empty demo room with blank screens sits behind a glass wall.

Image generated with ChatGPT

A strong vendor selection process for martech tests one or two preferred vendors deeply on your own data, systems, and contract terms, in place of a multi-vendor demo bake-off. Most B2B buyers have ranked a favorite before they first talk to a seller, and that favorite usually wins.

Key Takeaways

  • Most B2B buyers rank a favorite vendor before talking to any seller, and that favorite wins 82% of the time.
  • A demo shows the vendor's data and best people. Your data, integrations, team, and contract terms go untested.
  • Testing one vendor deeply works at any budget, because you size the pilot to the size of the contract.
  • Expect to give up part of your bargaining power on price and to own the decision yourself, with no committee spreadsheet to share the blame.

Publicis, the French advertising holding company, has won Microsoft, LVMH, Tiffany & Co., Paramount, and PepsiCo’s global media business in the past year without a competitive pitch (1. Faull, 2026). When Cindy Rose, chief executive of the London-based holding company WPP, warned analysts against “encouraging clients to bypass proper due diligence,” Publicis answered with an open letter to her. Its sharpest line was “skipping an old-school pitch circus isn’t skipping due diligence” (1. Faull, 2026).

Martech buying runs its own version of that circus. You write a request for proposal (RFP), invite 4 or 5 vendors, sit through 2 rounds of demos, score everyone on a spreadsheet, and negotiate with the top 2. The bigger the contract, the bigger the production. The vendor flies in its best technical presenter, builds a custom demo environment, and sends a VP to the final round.

Everyone treats that process as the protection. Mostly it protects the people who ran it, because if the purchase fails, they can point to the process. Real protection comes from testing one or two favorites deeply on your own data, systems, and contract terms, and that works at any budget.

The shortlist is decided before the first demo

The bake-off assumes buyers walk in neutral and let the demos decide. Most arrive with a favorite. 6sense, a company that sells account-targeting software to B2B sales teams, surveyed 4,611 recent B2B buyers for its 2026 buyer study. By the time those buyers first spoke with a seller, nearly all had already ranked their shortlist, and the favorite at that point won 82% of the time (2. 6sense, 2026). 6sense publishes that research to help vendors sell. Read from the buyer’s side, it says something else: 4 vendors in a bake-off usually means 1 favorite and 3 vendors there to make the choice look tested.

The other 3 still cost you. They cost weeks of meetings, scoring sessions, and security reviews for products you were never going to buy. They cost the vendors too, and vendors pass costs back. Forrester, the research and advisory firm, has made the same point about agency pitches: marketers end up paying for them indirectly (3. Forrester, 2023). In many cases, martech works the same way. A vendor that spends 6 months winning your deal often prices those 6 months into the contract.

What a demo proves, and what it leaves out

A demo proves the vendor can make its product look good with its own data, its best technical presenter, and a script it has run hundreds of times. That’s real information, and it’s the least useful information you’ll get, because the things that sink martech purchases never appear in it.

What sinks them comes after the signature. Your customer data shows up with its duplicates and missing fields. The product has to connect to your customer relationship management system (CRM), where sales tracks every account, and to the marketing automation platform you already run. The people on your team have to configure it every day. And the contract decides what happens at renewal. That’s the work a demo moves onto your team, and a second round of demos from a third vendor tests none of it.

Buyers also know what they’re looking for before the demos start. The same 6sense study found that 85% of buyers had largely or entirely set their decision criteria by the time they first contacted a seller (2. 6sense, 2026). What they still don’t have is proof against those criteria from their own environment.

“Only PepsiCo can buy this way”

Jay Wilson, a VP analyst in the marketing practice at Gartner, told The Drum that awarding business without a review makes sense only for the largest global marketers, who have the buying power to push for the best terms. “Most CMOs shouldn’t operate this way,” he said (1. Faull, 2026).

I disagree. Wilson’s argument mixes up how much testing a company can afford with how many vendors it should test. Buying power changes how deep the testing goes, and the logic stays the same at every size.

A company spending $200,000 a year on a platform can run a 3-week paid pilot with its favorite vendor on a sample of its own data, plus 2 reference calls it finds on its own. An enterprise spending $5 million can run 90 days in a test copy of its setup, connected to its live systems. Both get more real testing than a bake-off delivers. Any sound approach to martech decisions scales this way: you size the effort to the stakes.

The approach has real costs. With one vendor in the room, you lose part of your bargaining power on price, because the vendor knows it’s the favorite. You keep part of it by holding a second vendor in reserve with a short written proposal and pricing, and by writing the pilot’s success criteria into the contract.

The bigger cost is accountability. A bake-off spreads the decision across a committee and a spreadsheet. Testing one vendor deeply puts the decision on your judgment, and some leaders will find that uncomfortable.

What going deep looks like

Pick your favorite and, if the race is close, one alternative. Then put the hours you would have spent on demos into 4 kinds of work.

  • Run a paid pilot on your data. Forrester recommended replacing free agency pitches with paid projects so both sides have something at stake (3. Forrester, 2023). Pay the vendor for a small, scoped pilot, and write down what success looks like before it starts. Have the people who’ll run the product every day do the configuration, with the vendor’s team coaching.
  • Find your own references. Ask the vendor which customers signed in the last 12 months, then find 2 more through peers or LinkedIn who run the same CRM you do.
  • Test your hardest integration first. Connect the pilot to the system that has caused you the most trouble.
  • Settle contract terms before the pilot ends. Negotiate a cap on renewal price increases, the right to exit if the vendor changes owners, data export rights, and dated commitments for the roadmap items you’re counting on. The vendor still needs to win at that point, which makes it the cheapest moment to ask.

For the groundwork that comes before any of this, including the one-page requirements brief every vendor should answer, see why buyers must build their own evaluation playbook.

The next time an RFP template lands on your desk, ask what each round of demos will prove that a paid pilot with your favorite vendor wouldn’t. If nobody can answer, cut the round.

About the Author

Gene De Libero, Independent Martech Advisor, Digital Mindshare LLC

Gene De Libero has spent more than 30 years in marketing technology as a user, buyer, seller, integrator, and advisor. He is the creator of the Marketing Technology Transformation® framework, writer of How Marketing Technology Works®, and Independent Martech Advisor at Digital Mindshare LLC, a New York consultancy serving CMOs whose stacks have stopped paying for themselves. Most martech investments fail because the organization was never built to use the technology. He fixes that.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is a vendor selection process for martech?

A vendor selection process is how a company decides which software vendor to buy from. In martech it usually means a written RFP, several rounds of vendor demos, and a scoring spreadsheet. A stronger version narrows to one or two favorites early and spends the saved time testing them on your own data and systems.

Should you run an RFP when buying marketing software?

Use a short written request to collect pricing, security answers, and contract terms from 2 or 3 vendors. Skip the long RFP with multiple demo rounds. B2B buyers usually rank a favorite before any seller contact, so extra demo rounds rarely change the outcome. Put that time into a paid pilot with your favorite vendor.

How do you run a paid pilot with a martech vendor?

Agree on a small scope, a fixed price, and a time limit, such as 3 weeks for a mid-size contract or 90 days for an enterprise platform. Use a sample of your own customer data. Connect your hardest integration first. Write down what success looks like before the pilot starts, and tie it to the contract.

Does testing only one vendor weaken your negotiating position?

A little. A vendor that knows it’s the favorite has less reason to cut its price. Keep a second vendor in the running with a short written proposal and pricing, without a demo round. Then negotiate renewal caps and exit terms before the pilot ends, while the vendor still needs to win your business.

Is a vendor demo worth anything?

Yes, early on. A first demo shows whether the product belongs on your shortlist and how the vendor explains it. How the product handles your data, your integrations, and your team’s daily work only shows up in your own environment. After the first demo, each additional demo adds less than an hour spent testing in your own environment.
References
  1. Faull, J. (2026). Publicis hits back at WPP’s Cindy Rose over ‘CEO handshake’ claims in blistering letter. The Drum. https://www.thedrum.com/news/publicis-hits-back-at-wpp-s-cindy-rose-over-ceo-handshake-claims-in-blistering-letter
  2. 6sense. (2026). The secret life of B2B buyers: 2026 B2B buyer experience report. 6sense. https://6sense.com/science-of-b2b/buyer-experience-report-2026/
  3. Forrester. (2023). Ditch the pitch: $12.5 billion per year is spent on a dysfunctional agency review process. Forrester. https://www.forrester.com/blogs/dysfunctional-agency-review-ditch-the-pitch/